nowwearetalking is about telecommunications and you. It's where you can become involved, have your say, and Telstra listens - on issues affecting all Australians and the telecommunications industry. nowwearetalking is managed by Telstra. Find out more about this site.

Customise Page

Customise topic view

Please select items below for your custom page.

Re-organising your page

Log in here

Forgotten your password?Use ssl security

Register now

Use ssl security

Customise topic view

Customising your topic view will tailor your user experience by only displaying content which is relevant to the topic/s you have selected.

This setting will apply site-wide and will remain applied until you wish to change it.

Customise your modules

Customise your modules allows you to add or remove panels of content which appear on the homepage.

These can be added to or removed from the homepage at any time.

Re-organising your page

SingTel Optus’ breathtaking hypocrisy



Topic: Broadband , Telstra

Tags:    accc  national-broadband-network  news  paul-osullivan  singtel-optus


SingTel Optus’ breathtaking hypocrisy

SingTel Optus must come clean on whether it has handed over its network information and stop misleading the public about the National Broadband Network (NBN).

Telstra's Director Government Relations, David Quilty, said that Telstra has complied voluntarily and on-time with every request for network information. The Government has publicly recognised Telstra's significant efforts in this regard (see below).

"It is a disgrace that SingTel Optus CEO Paul O'Sullivan continues to peddle the fallacy that Telstra is holding up the NBN.  Telstra has been trying to build this network since 2005 and we want to get on with the job as soon as possible,’ Mr Quilty said.

“Mr O’Sullivan’s hypocrisy is breathtaking.  For months, he fought tooth and nail for a prolonged extension of the NBN process.  On 4 May 2008, he told Alan Kohler on ABC Inside Business that:

“We've been very clear to the Government; we are seeking an extension of the deadline by at least five months from when the information is provided.”

“Mr O'Sullivan must come clean and say whether or not SingTel Optus has submitted its network information in response to the Government’s original request in February and the further request last month.   A simple YES or NO answer will suffice.

"As the chief beneficiary of the ACCC's below-cost unbundled local loop prices, SingTel Optus has a huge incentive to delay the NBN as long as possible so it can continue to ‘cherry pick’ in the big cities, while refusing to invest capital in its own HFC – the world’s laziest cable network.

"Shame on Mr O'Sullivan for playing these silly games as Australia’s economy loses an estimated $200 million of benefits every month that the NBN is not built."

Facts & quotes:

  • "The Government has already received a significant amount of information from Telstra that it is ready to provide to proponents. This can occur when proponents have certified appropriate security arrangements are in place.''
    Ministerial Media Release - 7 August 2008
  • A spokesman for Communications Minister Stephen Conroy yesterday confirmed Telstra had provided it with further information but said it was still being assessed to make sure it fitted with the finalised guidelines
    Herald Sun - 8 August 2008

Comments

Fernando Dias
43 comments

16 August 2008
11:09am

Comment Permalink

Mr Sullivan is trying to delay the NBN not just for ‘cherry pick’ in the big cities, but to give Optus time to look credible when the time comes to show what they got. Read the following article to see how Optus is just a big hot air ballon. Australians are being conned by the OTUS marketing machine. http://www.theage.com.au/news/iphone-insider/slow-optus-credits-iphone-3g-users-for-woes/2008/08/15/1218307197759.html


Gareth Horley
18 August 2008
5:01pm

Comment Permalink

obviousley fernando a love affair with optus, even gave us a link to sign up to an optus iphone plan. optus will do what ever they can to delay our NBN from being built, lets face it, who else has not only the resources but the know how to get it done right, all the compeditors only know how to make money from onselling a product, its just another typical optus attempts to get their name in the in the news as the underdog.


Becky Lucas
14 comments

19 August 2008
1:23am

Comment Permalink

David Quilty, good for pointing this out. You have the courage like Dr Phil, the one and only to see it like it is. I'm glad to see you are waving the Telstra banner and spotting this breathtaking hypocrisy from another competitor. I hope one day as a reward for your loyalty you can get promoted from government relations to public relations in the near future. Telstra needs more people like you.


Paige Whelan
2 comments

19 August 2008
9:23am

Comment Permalink

Singtels Hypocrisy is only matched by Telstra's hypocrisy, in asking it's under attack staff to sign "Dr Phil my pockets" farewell card as flies off after a long 3 years with a no doubt a large slice of the Telstra Executive $50 million....


Add a comment

 

You need to log in to post a comment