nowwearetalking is about telecommunications and you. It's where you can become involved, have your say, and Telstra listens - on issues affecting all Australians and the telecommunications industry. nowwearetalking is managed by Telstra. Find out more about this site.

Customise Page

Customise topic view

Please select items below for your custom page.

Re-organising your page

Log in here

Forgotten your password?Use ssl security

Register now

Use ssl security

Customise topic view

Customising your topic view will tailor your user experience by only displaying content which is relevant to the topic/s you have selected.

This setting will apply site-wide and will remain applied until you wish to change it.

Customise your modules

Customise your modules allows you to add or remove panels of content which appear on the homepage.

These can be added to or removed from the homepage at any time.

Re-organising your page

OPEL: the dog gets a bone!



Topic: Telstra , Shareholder

Tags:    3g-network  adsl  blog  fleas  opel  regional  rhonda-griffin


It hasn’t taken long for OPEL the dog to get a few fleas. All those finickity technical experts pointing out the improbability of trying to operate a wireless broadband service using the unlicensed radio spectrum in competition to garage door openers.

Then there is Unwired/Austar apparently not wanting to play “catch” with mangy OPEL by making their spectrum and technology available – ex poste, poste haste (Opel bid waves a different standard - www.australianit.news.com).

But at last the poor dog gets a bone. Vodafone and Optus are reportedly exploring a joint venture sharing the spectrum they both have which, coincidentally, allows them to provide 3G services at a frequency much more suited to wide-area rural coverage.

"We are looking at a number of options, including another network sharing deal and going to 900MHz," Vodafone Australia chief Russell Hewitt said.

This covers about 55 per cent of the population, but the company would not aim to extend 3G everywhere, Mr Hewitt said.

"We are not entering the 98 per cent coverage game."
Telcos mull a 3G joint venture (www.australianit.news.com.au)

Strange. Though it is the right technology fit, Mr Hewitt has ruled out rural coverage under the venture – a little too quickly I thought.

Ditching the WiMAX idea and using the government funds to build a 3G network in competition to Telstra’s NextG™ allows them to provide both mobile voice and fixed/mobile data services. It’s the logical solution.

Logical, but not what they were given the money for, which is probably why there is absolutely no mention of the “O” word in this story. It’s outrageous enough that OPEL was given money to replicate ADSL technology in outer metropolitan areas and major regional cities. Seeing taxpayer dollars subsidising a commercial JV of 3G in the bush would be unconscionable. But, let’s keep watching.

Comments

Jason Torrento
4 July 2007
5:34pm

Comment Permalink

Yes, Garage Door Openers, I see what you are saying Rhonda. Wait. What Farmer Has A Garage Door Opener, let alone, A GARAGE DOOR ? I'm sure he would appreciate the luxury of, after spending all day in the field, digging holes, planting seeds, harvesting crops, and he gets back to the shed at the end of the day in the rain and thinks.. Gee.. Where's my garage door opener, I don't want to get any MORE wet?

Stuart Chappell
5 July 2007
10:15am

Comment Permalink

Last night (04/07/07) on the ABC the crew from the program "Chasers War on Everything" were up to their usual no good pranks. They had come up with the idea of selling the naming rights to the cyclones which were doing a lot of damage to Australias top end. They approached the National Australia Bank , Commonwealth Bank and the Wheatboard. Finally they turned up at one of the Telstra buildings and confronted a staff member about naming the next cyclone "Telstra". This guy was very clued in and asked where the cyclones were heading, when told they were around the top of WA and NT he said "Go see Optus, they are no where to be found up there", after all the ads on TV and in the paper where Optus is putting Telstra down i'd say this commoent has to be one of the best comebacks ever. This bloke deserves a medal. Well Done whoever you are

Jay Whittaker
6 July 2007
1:55pm

Comment Permalink

Jason Torrento. Not all people in rural areas are farmers planting seeds or harvesting crops. You dont even need to go far out of regional centres to find places where ADSL is not viable. Jason, I dont think you see what Rhonda is saying at all. You missed the point considerably.

Paul Hunneybell
6 July 2007
4:29pm

Comment Permalink

Hi Jason, Very intelligent once again. Consider lets say in 10 years time, if the farmer doesnt want to go down to paddock "F" when he's at paddock "A", but he needs the gate closed because some idiot was too busy spouting off about "garage doors" to do his work, so he uses his Next IP technology to close the gate for him. Not so far off as you'd think.

Geoff Stark
7 July 2007
12:06am

Comment Permalink

Jason, why am I feeding ignorance by replying? Then again you didn't actually reply to the argument you did however just employ your usual stamp of ignorance by having a go at the whole concept of farmers with garage door openers as it would be a luxury for them. I could go into how contemptuous you argument was of farmers as it is obvious you have no idea however I will just stay on the technical that somehow eludes you. Unlicensed spectrum in a radio frequency means it is open for disruption of any number of sources that are not monitored. This can be garage door opener, microwaves, any electrical equipment at all that is required by law not to interfere with the licensed spectrums but free to emit on the unlicensed wavelengths.

Jason Torrento
10 July 2007
1:41pm

Comment Permalink

No, you all missed the point. The likelihood of something interupting the 5.8Ghz wavelength in those areas is very unlikely. I've lived out in areas such as that, and really, there isn't much that even comes close to interupting that frequency. I think the whole subject of unlicensed spectrum has been blown entirely out of proportion with the assistance of this website and its misleading directives to the point where the argument in the media is about a very, very unlikely scenario. I've said it before, here it is again. Any issues with the WiMAX rollout are likely to be identified within the initial 6 months. If an issue pops up, they are likely to slow it down, find a solution, and move on. On the other hand, if a problem develops later, they can always just upgrade technology at that point in time, as the towers and infrastructure would already be built!

Dan Warne
10 July 2007
10:28pm

Comment Permalink

It's more probable that Vodafone is looking at a joint venture with Three, given Telstra screwed Three over by signing up for a JV with them and then promptly built the Next G network. Of course, that would depend on when Telstra's JV with Three runs out, I guess.

Rhonda Griffin
11 July 2007
4:34pm

Comment Permalink

Jason - the garage door story is just the most visual joke in a whole slew of problems with the OPEL WiMAX ambit. They will need a tower every 900 metres to provide BB on the 5.8Ghz spectrum unless there is direct line of sight. The whole thing is completely ridiculous.

Jason Torrento
13 July 2007
3:51pm

Comment Permalink

Tower every 900 meters? Really Rhonda? Care to provide facts around that? Because as far as I know, they can have them spread much further than 900m apart. Don't let facts get in the way of your agenda push.. By all means, let it continue. It just backs up my argument that this website will do what it can to mislead its viewers. WiMAX towers under the OPEL proposal are going to, and can be, 20km apart, feel free to provide facts saying that they NEED to be 900m apart. Credible facts.

Ian Thomson
16 November 2007
10:10am

Comment Permalink

Is your writer on OPELS plans so naive as to believe that Telstra's CDMA network was not paid for by the taxpayers who owned the company.All the new towers being rushed up to give telstra some pretence of a service while being handed an absolute monopoly,( wnere country people are concerned ), are being paid for by 'emergency funds' salted away before 'privatisation' by fronts like Telstra Countrywide. Yours IAN

Add a comment

 

You need to log in to post a comment